The Things We Carry and The Stories We Tell Ourselves

by Ben Rea, LCSW

The way we show up in the world today didn't happen overnight. Our reactions, beliefs, and behaviors are often shaped by experiences we've carried with us for years, sometimes without even realizing it.

Maybe you become defensive when someone offers feedback, even when they aren't criticizing you. Perhaps you avoid difficult conversations because conflict feels overwhelming. You might spend a lot of time anticipating what could go wrong, trying to stay one step ahead of disappointment, rejection, or failure.

Or maybe you have become so accustomed to being the responsible one, the strong one, or the person who keeps everything together that you rarely stop to consider what you actually need.

And sometimes, after reacting in a way you didn't intend, you find yourself wondering, "Why am I like this?"

These patterns can be frustrating, especially when we recognize that they are affecting our relationships, our confidence, and our ability to feel connected to the people around us.

But what if we approached these patterns with curiosity instead of criticism?

Our thoughts, emotional responses, and behaviors don't develop in isolation. They are shaped by our experiences, relationships, environments, and the ways we learned to navigate the world.

Some of the patterns we struggle with today may have started as ways of protecting ourselves. The challenge is that what once helped us feel safe may no longer be helping us live the life we want.

Understanding this connection can be an important part of changing how we relate to ourselves and others.

Your past doesn't stay in the past quite as neatly as you might think

The brain is constantly learning from experience. It notices patterns, makes predictions, and uses previous experiences to help us respond to what is happening now.

This is an important survival function. If a particular situation has been associated with danger, rejection, or emotional pain, we may become more sensitive to similar cues in the future.

Consider someone who grew up in an environment where mistakes were met with criticism. They may have learned to be extremely careful, double-check their work, and avoid situations where they might fail.

As an adult, those same tendencies might show up as perfectionism, procrastination, difficulty accepting feedback, or an overwhelming fear of disappointing others.

Or perhaps you grew up in a home where emotions were unpredictable. You may have become very skilled at reading other people's moods, anticipating their needs, and adjusting your behavior to avoid conflict.

Those skills may have helped you navigate an earlier environment. But today, they might leave you feeling responsible for everyone else's emotions.

These are examples of how past experiences can influence present behavior. They are not proof of trauma or a diagnosis. They are invitations to become curious about the patterns we have developed.

The goal isn't to blame our past for everything that happens in the present. It is to understand how our experiences may have shaped the ways we think, feel, and respond.

The stories we learn to tell about ourselves

Our experiences shape more than our behavior. They can also influence the stories we develop about who we are.

Think about some of the messages you may have absorbed throughout your life:

  • I'm too sensitive.

  • I have to be perfect to be accepted.

  • I can't depend on anyone.

  • I need to keep everyone happy.

  • I'm not good enough.

  • I always mess things up.

  • I have to be strong because no one else will take care of things.

Over time, these messages can become deeply familiar. We may stop recognizing them as interpretations and begin treating them as facts.

For example, a person who experienced repeated criticism may come to believe they are fundamentally inadequate. Someone who experienced unpredictable relationships may believe that closeness inevitably leads to disappointment. Someone who was praised primarily for achievement may begin to associate their worth with productivity and performance.

The story becomes a lens through which new experiences are interpreted.

When someone offers constructive feedback, the person who believes they are inadequate may hear confirmation that they aren't good enough. When a partner needs space, someone who fears rejection may interpret it as evidence that they are no longer wanted.

The experience itself may be relatively ordinary. But the meaning attached to it can be powerful.

This is one reason self-awareness matters. We can begin to recognize the difference between what is happening and the story we are telling ourselves about what is happening.

And sometimes, that distinction changes everything.

When self-protection becomes a pattern

Many behaviors that create difficulty in adulthood began as reasonable attempts to manage uncomfortable experiences.

Avoidance, for example, can provide immediate relief.

If social situations make you anxious, staying home may reduce that anxiety. If conflict feels threatening, avoiding difficult conversations may help you feel calmer. If you worry about making mistakes, procrastinating may temporarily protect you from the possibility of failure.

The problem is that short-term relief can reinforce the behavior.

When we avoid something and feel better immediately afterward, the brain can learn that avoidance was the solution. Over time, this may make the situation feel even more difficult to approach.

This process is often called negative reinforcement. In behavioral psychology, negative reinforcement means that a behavior becomes more likely because it removes or reduces something uncomfortable.

It does not mean the behavior is bad or that someone is doing something wrong.

It simply helps explain why certain patterns can become so persistent.

For example:

  1. You feel anxious about a difficult conversation.

  2. You decide not to have it.

  3. Your anxiety decreases.

  4. Your brain learns that avoiding the conversation brought relief.

  5. The next difficult conversation may feel even harder to approach.

The same cycle can occur with social anxiety, perfectionism, procrastination, reassurance-seeking, and emotional withdrawal.

These patterns often make sense when we understand what they are trying to accomplish. They may be attempts to avoid rejection, maintain control, prevent disappointment, or protect us from feeling vulnerable.

The difficulty is that protection and connection don't always coexist comfortably. Sometimes the very strategies we use to protect ourselves prevent us from experiencing the relationships and opportunities we want.

When the problem starts to feel like your identity

There is an important distinction between experiencing a problem and becoming defined by it.

Consider the difference between saying:

"I'm an anxious person."

And saying:

"Anxiety has been showing up in my life, particularly when I feel uncertain or out of control."

The first statement can make anxiety feel like a permanent part of who you are. The second creates a little distance. It allows you to examine when anxiety appears, what influences it, and how you might respond differently.

This distinction is central to an approach called narrative therapy.

Narrative therapy recognizes that people make sense of their lives through stories. These stories are influenced by relationships, culture, family expectations, significant experiences, and the meanings we attach to events.

Sometimes those stories become narrow. We begin to focus primarily on our mistakes, limitations, disappointments, or painful experiences.

A person may tell themselves they are a failure because of one difficult period in their life. Someone else may see themselves as a bad parent because they struggle with patience. Another person may believe they are incapable of maintaining healthy relationships because of previous experiences.

Narrative therapy invites us to examine these conclusions rather than automatically accepting them as the complete truth.

It also introduces an important idea: You are not the problem. The problem is the problem.

This doesn't mean avoiding responsibility for our actions. It means separating our identity from the difficulties we experience.

You can struggle with anxiety without being defined by anxiety. You can experience depression without that experience representing your entire identity. You can recognize patterns that have hurt your relationships without deciding that you are incapable of change.

When we create some distance between ourselves and the problem, we have more room to understand it, challenge it, and develop new ways of responding.

Looking for the stories that have been overlooked

One of the most powerful parts of narrative therapy is exploring the parts of our stories that may have been overlooked.

When we are focused on a problem, we tend to notice the experiences that reinforce it.

If you believe you are not good enough, you may remember every mistake while overlooking the times you showed competence, resilience, or courage.

If you believe you are difficult to love, you may focus on relationships that didn't work while discounting the people who have shown genuine care and connection.

If you believe you are incapable of change, you may overlook the many ways you have already adapted throughout your life.

Narrative therapy calls attention to these alternative experiences. They are sometimes described as unique outcomes, moments when a person responded differently than the problem would have predicted.

For example:

  • You spoke up even though you were afraid of disappointing someone.

  • You allowed yourself to make a mistake without becoming consumed by self-criticism.

  • You asked for help instead of trying to manage everything alone.

  • You stayed present during a difficult conversation rather than withdrawing.

  • You recognized an old pattern and made a different choice.

These moments matter.

They provide evidence that your story is more complicated than the version you may have been telling yourself.

The goal isn't to replace a negative story with an unrealistically positive one. It is to develop a fuller, more balanced understanding of who you are, including your values, strengths, relationships, choices, and capacity for change.

Making room for difficult thoughts and emotions

While narrative therapy helps us examine the stories we tell about ourselves, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) offers another useful perspective.

ACT focuses on developing psychological flexibility. This means learning to stay connected to the present, make room for difficult internal experiences, and take actions that reflect what matters to us.

One of the central ideas in ACT is that we don't have to eliminate every uncomfortable thought or feeling before we can move forward.

Think about how much energy we sometimes spend trying not to feel something.

We avoid situations that might make us anxious. We distract ourselves from sadness. We try to control every detail because uncertainty feels uncomfortable. We criticize ourselves for having emotions we believe we shouldn't have.

Unfortunately, the struggle to control our internal experiences can sometimes become another source of distress.

ACT introduces a process called cognitive defusion. Rather than treating every thought as an unquestionable truth, we practice noticing thoughts as thoughts.

For example, instead of saying:

"I'm going to fail."

You might practice saying:

"I notice the thought or feeling that I'm going to fail."

The situation hasn't changed, and the thought may still be present. But you have created a little space between the thought and your response.

That space is powerful.

That space can help you decide what you want to do next.

You might still feel anxious and choose to have the conversation. You might still experience self-doubt and apply for the opportunity. You might feel uncomfortable setting a boundary and decide to communicate your needs anyway.

The goal isn't to stop having difficult thoughts. It is to stop allowing every difficult thought to make your decisions.

Understanding your triggers without judging yourself

A trigger is a cue that activates a strong emotional or physical response. It might be a particular tone of voice, a facial expression, a disagreement, a feeling of being ignored, or even a situation that resembles something from the past.

Triggers are not always dramatic. Sometimes they appear in ordinary moments.

You might notice your heart rate increasing during a conversation, feel an immediate urge to defend yourself, or become unusually quiet when someone expresses disappointment.

Rather than immediately judging the reaction, try approaching it with curiosity.

Ask yourself:

  • What happened immediately before I felt this way?

  • What did I assume was happening?

  • What did I notice in my body?

  • Does this situation remind me of something familiar?

  • What am I trying to protect myself from?

  • What story am I telling myself about this situation?

  • Is that story the only possible explanation?

  • What response would reflect the person I want to be?

These questions help bring awareness to the relationship between past experiences, present emotions, and current behavior.

They also create an opportunity to distinguish between an old pattern and a present-day choice.

Not every emotional reaction comes from the past, and not every difficult experience needs to be interpreted through a trauma lens. Sometimes we are responding to something genuinely difficult happening right now.

The point is not to overanalyze every interaction. It is to develop enough awareness to recognize when an old story may be influencing how we experience the present.

Creating a different relationship with your past

Understanding where a pattern came from is not the same as being permanently defined by it.

Perhaps you learned to avoid conflict because conflict once felt unsafe. Perhaps you became highly independent because relying on others was disappointing. Perhaps you developed perfectionistic tendencies because achievement became a way to feel valued.

These experiences matter. They deserve compassion, not criticism.

But you can acknowledge where a pattern came from while also asking whether it still serves you.

A helpful place to begin is by considering some questions:

What did I learn?

What beliefs or behaviors developed from my experiences? What did I learn about relationships, trust, emotions, achievement, or my own worth?

How has that learning affected me?

Does the pattern help me today, or does it create distance, anxiety, resentment, or unnecessary pressure? What might it be costing me?

What do I want to practice instead?

What matters to me now? How would I respond if I weren't automatically following the same old pattern? What small action could move me toward the kind of relationships and life I want?

This is where narrative therapy and ACT complement one another.

We can begin to question the stories that have shaped our identity while also identifying the values we want to guide our choices.

Instead of organizing our lives around avoiding rejection, perhaps we want to prioritize meaningful connection.

Instead of organizing our lives around perfection, perhaps we want to prioritize growth, creativity, or self-respect.

Instead of trying to control every possible outcome, perhaps we want to practice flexibility, courage, and trust.

We may not get to choose everything that happens to us. But we can work toward having more choice in how we respond.

You are more than the things you carry

Our past experiences are part of our stories. They influence how we understand ourselves, how we relate to others, and how we respond to uncertainty.

But they are not the whole story.

You can recognize that anxiety has shaped your decisions without allowing anxiety to define your identity. You can acknowledge that certain experiences have made relationships difficult without deciding that meaningful connection is out of reach. You can take responsibility for patterns you want to change without treating yourself as someone who is fundamentally broken.

Sometimes growth begins when we stop asking, "What's wrong with me?" and start asking, "What have I learned, what am I carrying, and what do I want to do differently?"

That shift doesn't erase the past. It creates room for something new.

You don't have to reject the person you became to begin becoming someone who responds differently.

When therapy can help

It can be difficult to recognize our own patterns, particularly when they have become familiar ways of thinking and responding.

Therapy can provide a space to explore how past experiences influence present behavior, identify emotional triggers, and understand the beliefs and stories that may contribute to anxiety, avoidance, or self-criticism.

Narrative therapy can help you examine the stories you have developed about yourself and identify experiences that offer a fuller picture of who you are. ACT can help you develop a different relationship with difficult thoughts and feelings while taking action that reflects your values.

Trauma-informed therapy does not assume that every difficulty is caused by trauma. Instead, it approaches each person's experiences with an understanding of how stress, relationships, and significant life events can shape the way we respond to the world.

The goal isn't to erase your history or convince yourself that everything is positive. It is to help you understand your experiences without allowing them to define every possibility ahead of you.

If you're looking for therapy in San Luis Obispo, I offer a supportive space to explore anxiety, emotional patterns, trauma-related concerns, and personal growth.

Sometimes the first step toward change is simply beginning to understand the story you've been telling yourself.

As always, I’m here to help.

Ben

Academic references and further reading

  • Beck, A. T., & Haigh, E. A. P. (2014). Advances in cognitive theory and therapy: The generic cognitive model. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 10, 1–24.

  • Craske, M. G., Treanor, M., Conway, C. C., Zbozinek, T., & Vervliet, B. (2014). Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 58, 10–23.

  • Hayes, S. C., Strosahl, K. D., & Wilson, K. G. (2012). Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: The Process and Practice of Mindful Change (2nd ed.). Guilford Press.

  • Brewin, C. R., Dalgleish, T., & Joseph, S. (1996). A dual representation theory of posttraumatic stress disorder. Psychological Review, 103(4), 670–686.

Next
Next

ADHD Isn't Always a Straight Line: ADHD Over Time